2025's Most Underrated Towns In New Jersey

New Jersey sits between some of America's biggest and greatest cities but isn't really notable for having any of its own. To some, this discounts it as a proper vacation destination, but to others (perhaps you), this makes it all the more unique and interesting. And why not explore something new in 2025?

Today, we will cover some of New Jersey's best-hidden gems, from the easy-to-reach suburbs of cities like New York City and Philadelphia to more remote destinations in the state's gorgeous and underrated wildlands. With these spots in mind, you can see another side of the Garden State that not all get to experience and make some long-lasting memories along the way.

Mount Holly

Mount Holly offers an authentic Jersey experience with fewer crowds than nearby cities in the southern end of the state. Despite its proximity to Philadelphia, Mount Holly has avoided the over-commercialization seen in other suburban areas, and makes for a breath of fresh air for city folk looking for an escape in 2025.

The downtown area is a great place to start your adventures here and is anchored in most part by Mill Race Village, a cool collection of independent shops and stores housed in a number of historic buildings. Dining options like the Village Idiot Brewing Company and Kitchen 87 are highly recommended if you need to grab a bite, and the area's walkable layout makes it easy to explore on foot, wherever else you may go.

The Burlington County Prison Museum, a National Historic Landmark, is an especially interesting local attraction for history buffs, and offers you a look into the town's oftentimes dark past with its meticulously preserved cells, many of which come with eerie tales of hauntings and other dark stories.

For something a little less dour, nature lovers will find plenty to explore at nearby Rancocas State Park, where trails wind through wetlands and forest, providing a natural respite just minutes from town.

Red Bank

Explore a quieter side of the Jersey Shore in Red Bank. Many come to experience its vibrant arts scene, which is anchored by the historic Count Basie Center for the Arts. This year, you will be able to see a number of concerts, theater productions, and film screenings here. There is much more in store for you at this destination, however, from pristine parks to must-visit stops within its fertile countryside.

Red Bank’s location near the mouth of the Navesink River provides you with picturesque spots like the Riverside Gardens Park, just steps from downtown. Take a look at Riverside Gardens Park, which features several historic landmarks.

With current health trends prioritizing organic, locally made food, Red Bank Farmers Market has also played an essential role in the local economy. Open between Mother's Day and mid-November in 2025; you can pick up some locally grown produce or some handcrafted goods made by regional artisans while visiting in the warmer months.

Cape May Court House

Cape May Court House, located inland from the bustling beaches of Cape May, is a less commercialized alternative to New Jersey’s more popular coastal destinations.

Here, you will find a mix of locally owned shops, antique stores, and dining options that highlight regional flavors, namely fresh seafood caught nearby. Cape May Court House also has a strong focus on supporting local agriculture. Nearby farms and vineyards provide fresh produce, and seasonal farmers’ markets offer visitors a chance to sample local goods. If wine caught your eye, small local vineyards like Jessie Creek Winery have been growing in popularity in 2025, or partake in a guided tour this summer season with Day Sipper Wine and Brew Tours.

The historical centerpiece of the area is the ornate 1920s-era Cape May County Courthouse (the clear inspiration for the community's name), and for a deeper dive into history, the historic John Holmes House offers a glimpse into colonial life through its collections of artifacts and available local tours.

The region is also home to the Cape May County Park & Zoo, a well-maintained, free-admission zoo with over 500 animals and expansive park grounds ideal for picnics and nature walks, a nice, budget-friendly option for today's economy.

Frenchtown

Frenchtown, situated along the banks of the Delaware River, is an underrated gem and a surprisingly quiet community given its position between the metros of Philadelphia and New York City.

The town’s scenic setting on the river is a big draw, and locales like the Delaware and Raritan Canal State Park Trail offer space for hiking, biking, and simply enjoying river viewpoints that don't see the same crowds that many other northeastern parks will likely see in 2025. Kayakers and canoeists can also access the water directly from town, with several boat launches located nearby.

If you're in the area, be sure to explore the town’s past through guided tours in the Frenchtown Historic District, where landmarks date back to its earliest days, like The National Hotel (a still functioning accommodation, too) and a collection of flat brick store fronts can be enjoyed.

Haddonfield

Haddonfield is a historic community sitting right on the outskirts of Camden. If you live in the city and don't want to spend the money on traveling somewhere distant, check this location out this year for an easy, budget-friendly trip. At the very least, its colonial-style architecture, much of which can be found in its compact downtown core, makes this town a picturesque urban spot to take a walk in.

One of Haddonfield’s standout features is actually its connection to paleontology. The town is home to Hadrosaurus foulkii, the first nearly complete dinosaur skeleton found in North America. A statue commemorates the discovery, and visitors can explore the nearby excavation site. You can learn more about Haddonfield itself, too, at Greenfield Hall, which gives you a window into early colonial life through its many exhibits and guided tours.

Support this community's currently growing art scene as well this year at the Haddonfield Crafts and Fine Art Festival, which draws local artists and features hundreds of booths in which you can pick up something new for your home.

Lambertville

If you're in the mood to shop at some truly unique locations this season, Lambertville may be just for you. Start your day in this small town along the Delaware River at the Golden Nugget Antique Market. Operating since 1967, it's a hidden Garden State Gem, offering vintage finds and curiosities that you may not be able to find elsewhere.

While in the area, be sure to look out for its abundance of historic architecture too, much of which dates back to the 18th and 19th centuries. The Holcombe Jimison Farmstead Museum is something we recommend if this interests you.

Lambertville is also a community that likes to support its local talent, which can be seen at events like Shad Fest, where artists, musicians, and local vendors alike take center stage.

Lambertville’s location on the river provides access to some must-see trails, as well as the Goat Hill Overlook Trailhead, which overlooks the town and its dense forestlands surrounding it; an idyllic, less visited spot to see the fall foliage in 2025. Visitors can also walk or bike to nearby New Hope, Pennsylvania, via a pedestrian-friendly bridge.

Cranbury

Cranbury is known for its commitment to preserving green spaces, with an excellent array of places where you can go for a scenic walk or bike ride. Sitting between Trenton and New York City, you can make this your new go-to spot for a bit of easily accessible outdoor adventure in 2025.

Village Park, located along Brainerd Lake, contains a network of walking trails, picnic areas, and access to boating and fishing on its lake. You can delve deeper in the town's wildlands at the Cranbury Preserve, located along Cranbury Brook, which runs through the heart of town, then eventually into Brainerd Lakes and beyond.

If you're taking a stroll in Cranbury, try to make a stop at the Cranbury Museum too. Located in a home built in 1834, this unique landmark displays local history through curated exhibits and artifacts within the period accurate structure.

Whether exploring its tree-lined streets, enjoying a meal at a local eatery, or taking a quiet walk along the lake, Cranbury is a refreshing alternative to busier central New Jersey destinations.

Highlands

Highlands is yet another coastal town that often flies under the radar compared to its busier Jersey Shore neighbors. Its location at the northern tip of the shore provides you with access to both sandy beaches and a plethora of lush green spaces for you to enjoy this summer.

The town’s proximity to the Gateway National Recreation Area at Sandy Hook also allows you to venture around seven miles of clean beaches, hiking and biking trails, and historic sites like the Sandy Hook Lighthouse, the oldest operating lighthouse in the United States. Highlands is also home to the Twin Lights State Historic Site, which offers unobstructed views of the Atlantic Ocean and a museum that delves into the region's maritime history.

As with any coastal town, Highland's waterfront is home to several highly rated independent seafood restaurants. Proving Ground Waterfront Dining or Bahrs Landing Famous Seafood Restaurant & Marina are nice higher-end options, while Saltwater Bar and Kitchen is in a relaxed setting with tasty yet more affordable dishes to match.

Getting to Highlands is simple and convenient, with the SeaStreak Ferry providing easy access to Manhattan.

Uncover the Garden State's Best Gems this Year

Whether you are looking to spend time during the summer on the Atlantic Coast or want to get a taste of history in some of America's oldest settlements, these destinations should definitely make your to-do list this year. Get a fresh seafood meal on the Jersey Shore, hop into the great outdoors in Frenchtown, or simply find some respite from big city life in boroughs like Mount Holly and Cranbury. The options to find adventure and try something new are endless if you just know where to look.