7 Cutest Small Towns In the Finger Lakes To Visit In 2024
If wineries, waterfalls, gorges, and auto-races get your heart beating, why not enjoy it all lakeside, in the heart of the Finger Lakes? Steeped in history and spoiled in natural beauty, the region's eleven unique lakes are gem-studded along the shores. Cute as buttons, each town has a unique vibe, heritage, and family attractions, and it really feels like an escape from life, as you know it in the city. Penn Yan is one of the cutest towns in New York, with wineries, great breakfast options, and a historic inn straight from Little Women.
The First Presbyterian Church in Bath, the town along the Cohocton River, is one of eight Tiffany glass sanctuaries in the entire country, while Geneseo, a college town, features Geneseo Riviera, the city's downtown, just 30 miles from Rochester, near the Pennsylvania border. Verona Beach is a generations-long destination to reconnect with nature, bond with family, and celebrate events with waterfront cottages, while Naples, the Grape Pie Capital in the World, home to Grimes Glen Park with wildflowers and two refreshing 60-foot waterfalls, offers a haunted stay at the Naples Hotel.
Aurora
Aurora, one of the Finger Lakes' cutest, is a college town with a rich culture and many interesting landmarks, like the infamous Aurora Inns; worth a shot even if you're not staying there. Morgan Opera House is a beautiful Victoriana in a half-timbered Tudor-Revival building, complete with a library. Home to Wells College and its notable graduate, Pleasant Rowland, the creator and founder of the American Girl Doll Company, she returned to this "life-changing" town, according to her interview with Vogue, 25 years after graduating. Many of the beautiful, restored homes from disrepair and some of the thriving businesses are her legacy.
Located in Cayuga County on the eastern shore of Cayuga Lake, visitors can enjoy lakeside recreation and watersports, as well as the student talent from the liberal arts college through galleries and live art in the area. A one-road town, Aurora more than makes up for her size with generous attractions and admirable lakeside mansions as part of the 21st-century renaissance. Once home to elegant family estates and a prep school for girls in Upstate New York, today, Trader Rose is an antique store, while for a great dinner after a day of shopping or lounging at Lake Glass Beach, Fargo Bar & Grill is waterside and delicious.
Bath
Bath, a destination for the longest, continuously-running county fair in the US, is undeniably cute! Nestled minutes south of the uniquely shaped Keuka Lake, its historic grandeur of buildings and architecture, as well as the grand town square, maximize the small town appeal away from the tourist crowds. Favored by generations since its founding days in 1793, Bath, the county seat, is steeped in history and surrounded by rich agriculture and small, family-owned farms. Today, it is a destination for live music, traditional celebrations, and modern-day events, while the cuisine is always fresh and local, like at Stephanie's or the many markets around, which makes it no wonder about the oldest fair!
Founded by William Pulteney along the Cohocton River through the southern portion, visitors enjoy the understated charm of a namesake famous town in England and waterside recreation both ways. Take a morning riverside stroll after breakfast at the Chat-A-Whyle Restaurant, ending the day at sunset over the lake. In between, the active can enjoy watersports on the Y-shaped lake, which is so fun to explore, or strolls downtown, with sites and shopping gravitating towards Pulteney Square. The First Presbyterian Church, one of eight Tiffany glass sanctuaries in the entire country, may be open to admire the beauty from the translucent inside.
Geneseo
Geneseo, a cute town with a diverse culture and a unique character, appeals to those looking for a lakeside escape out of the ordinary. Nestled in a valley 35 miles south of Rochester, it is just minutes east of the beautiful Conesus Lake. The Village of Geneseo thrives in the constant beauty of the Valley as a tourist destination, with outfitters and other small-town businesses near the Pennsylvania border and an innovative spirit of a college town where the students like to study or relax along the banks in the warmer months.
Home to just under 10,000, Geneseo is quaint in the summer, while the college grounds stay open for tours of the Geneseo Campus. Nearby, the refreshing Long Point Park is great for a stroll and picnics. From fishing to swimming, bird watchers can enjoy the large migratory bird population in the area. Bursting with venues to relax and stay culturally entertained, the Geneseo Riviera, the city's downtown, is steeped in over a century of history. Its vintage theatre offers musical and cinematic performances, while the Warplane National Museum is a family favorite for exhibits of historic military aircraft and the opportunity to ride with an expert on the BT-13 Basic Trainer.
Naples
Travel to Naples once and fall for its small-town charms forever after, including foodie pleasures, historical sites, and scenic natural parks. Turning many new faces into loyal tourists, Naples, home to Grimes Glen Park, is spoiled in natural beauty, from the seasonal wildflower display in spring to its two refreshing 60-foot waterfalls and the unique hemlocks, a type of tree. Nearby, the sprawling 900-acre Cumming Nature Centre is fantastic for a summertime stroll, with an observation deck over the beaver pond. Don't miss Monica’s Pie's best seller of a grape-stuffed slice or slab to bring home and share over tea time with friends and family, along with a variety of homemade jams, jellies, and seasonal surprises. The Naples Hotel, renowned for its hauntings, is a one-of-a-kind stay in the whole Finger Lakes region.
For easy scenery with little hiking, West Hill Preserve is part of the Finger Lakes Trail through a forested landscape, while the 5-star Bristol Valley Theatre in the heart of town presents professional theatrical productions. Make an evening out of wine tasting at Inspire Moore Winery after the must-hit local favorite, Roots Cafe, for dinner next door. The tiny size of Naples, one of the region's smallest towns, magnifies the picturesque nature around it and its immense food offerings, which is part of its appeal and a major draw to visit the namesake of an Italian city in the Empire State. Located in Ontario County, New York, near Honeoye and Canandaigua Lakes, welcome to the Grape Pie Capital of the World!
Penn Yan
It's easy to fall in love with Penn Yan, a cute town from every side, starting with its name and ending when you don't want to say goodbye to the sweet hosts at the Laurentide Inn, a historical yellow home right from Little Women with a great restaurant, True Roots Kitchen, and, bonus, their own brewery onsite! Nestled just off Keuka Lake to the north, Penn Yan, a play on the words “Pennsylvania” and "Yankee," is as all-American as it sounds, home to some Amish and Mennonites with clambering horses and buggies. Amity Coffee is a great idea to start the day running, or Penn Yan Diner when you just arrive before hitting the Keuka Outlet Trail, which features a waterfall!
Downtown Penn Yan, home to cute shops and outlets, is proud to offer Red Tail Ridge Winery for a feel-good pursuit in more ways than a tipsy daze, being the only one in the state that is LEED-gold certified. Kemmeter Wines is another gem in the area, while the aptly named Sweet Farm, a climate and animal sanctuary, is a haven for the kiddos to interact with rescued farm animals in rehabilitation. Promoting sustainability and regenerative agriculture, it hosts timely events and even visitors at the Sweet Farm House across the road. Indian Pines Park is waterfront with a playground, a family-friendly beach area for swimming or wading, and scenic views, while Seneca Farm, just a stroll away, will keep you coming on a hot summer day for the best ice cream treats of your life!
Verona Beach
Headed by two miles of sandy beach, this little villa on Oneida Lake is as dreamy as its name suggests. Whether you're on a lakeside escape or a family vacation of building sandcastles and sunbathing, Verona Beach State Park is a great place to relax in natural scenery year-round. Verona Beach is a generations-long destination to reconnect with nature, bond with family, and celebrate events, with waterfront cottages welcoming back old friends and new faces. From local RV parks and campgrounds, enjoy easy access to the vast lake scene, visible from anywhere in town. From fishing for walleye and bass to a beach volleyball game, watersport fans can enjoy every type of vessel to explore the lake. Don't miss the nearby church in the Oscar-nominated film The Sterile Cuckoo with Liza Minnelli in 1969, the site of her on-screen kiss.
Opened in 1897, Sylvan Beach Union Chapel, a historic interdenominational church on the waterfront in Sylvan Beach with unique top-hinge doors open to the shores, looks spectacular at sunset from the beach or a restaurant. The historic Verona Beach Lighthouse is great for a morning stroll along the path in seclusion before lakefront breakfast at the iconic Eddie’s for a famous hot ham sandwich at Canalview Cafe or at the Pancake House. There's family fun during Pirates Weekend in July and Canal Fest in August, as well as a nostalgic carnival spot with a gorgeous view of Oneida Lake from the top of Central New York’s largest roller coaster at Sylvan Beach Amusement Park nearby and the historic Carello’s Carousel Arcade with a classic carousel.
Watkins Glen
Watkins Glen, a town on the radar when in the region, stays cute and quaint with its pristine streets, nature, and Seneca Lake banks despite its popularity. Immensely proud to offer Watkins Glen International; this, one of America's most famous road racing tracks, attracts thrill seekers, while the annual Finger Lakes Wine Festival in July is perfect to coincide with your summertime visit to the cascading waterfalls at the enchanting Watkins Glen State Park. Comprising 19 magical waterfalls amid gorgeous verdancy, the cobbled pathways and bridges along the 1.5-mile Gorge Trail make this glen appear right from a fairy-tale book cover.
Come early or on a weekday to score a free parking spot literally across the street for two hours after throwing down your bags at the Watkins Glen Harbour Hotel, which offers a top breakfast. The cute lakeside town on the southern shore is more than auto racing and waterfalls; it has some of the region's prettiest lake views and landscapes for hikes. Don't miss the sweet and short trail with stairs to climb at the park, Pier House Seneca Lake, the nearby Blue Pointe Grille, and, just up the shore, Clute Park, a garden and park. From the Elf in the Oak to Glen Mountain Market Bakery, your drink of choice awaits at Wagner Vineyards or Horseheads Brewing Seneca Lake for beer and the best sunset from Seneca Harbor.
The eleven long, narrow lakes in west-central New York feature gems like Watkins Glen State Park, with its 19 magical waterfalls in verdant nature along cobbled pathways and bridges straight from a fairy-tale book cover. Once home to elegant family estates and a prep school for girls in Upstate New York, Aurora is famous for the Aurora Inns, lounging at Lake Glass Beach, and Morgan Opera House, a beautiful Victoriana in a half-timbered Tudor-Revival building.
These picturesque villages, close to each other, offer the sweetest escape with unique experiences against gorgeous lake views, from waterfront dining and shopping to scaling gorges, chasing waterfalls, and vino glasses after watersports and adventures while lounging at sunset over another lake—something from the bucket list of every type of traveler.
