7 Undiscovered Small Towns in the Finger Lakes Region

Bypass the usual suspects of the Empire State tourist scene and discover the hidden corners of the gems of the Finger Lakes Region, one of America's most coveted vacation spots. Naples, Aurora, Hammondsport, and many more are often overshadowed by their more celebrated neighbors. But if you want to experience a vacation like no other and to visit the less trodden paths of New York where the pace of life slows down, then you need to wander into the Finger Lakes Region. Whether it's the vintage charm of Aurora's rowhouses, the revolutionary roots of Geneva's agricultural scene, or the nautical heritage of Hammondsport, this guide invites you to explore the quiet depth of these seven towns, revealing why they are the Finger Lakes' true hidden gems.

Naples

Naples, often referred to as the "Grape Pie Capital of the World," remains one of the Finger Lakes' best-kept secrets. Situated between the rolling vineyards and orchards of Naples Valley and the scenic shores of Canandaigua Lake, this town offers a unique blend of culinary heritage and natural beauty. Each fall, the landscape transforms into a stunning display of autumnal colors, drawing a more local crowd that comes for the serene views and stays for the grape pies. The annual Grape Festival, a highlight since 1872, celebrates the local grape harvest with an array of grape pies, local wines, and crafts, attracting visitors who relish in local flavors and traditions. Despite its rich offerings, Naples remains relatively undiscovered, perhaps due to its more reserved festivities and the overshadowing fame of larger towns in the Finger Lakes region.

Naples is near natural wonders like the High Tor Wildlife Management Area and the challenging yet rewarding Conklin Gully 12 Falls Trail, providing abundant opportunities for hiking, wildlife observation, and embracing the tranquil outdoors. Meanwhile, the Bristol Valley Theater anchors the town’s cultural scene, offering performances that draw talent and audiences looking for quality entertainment in a picturesque setting. The blend of engaging outdoor activities and a thriving arts scene makes Naples a noteworthy destination for those looking to escape the more tourist-heavy areas of New York.

Aurora

Aurora is on the eastern shores of Cayuga Lake and is distinguished by its beautifully preserved 19th-century architecture and the historic Wells College, whose campus offers an educational journey back in time, having been founded in 1868. The college itself is a centerpiece of the village, listed on the National Register of Historic Places, not just for its educational legacy but for its striking campus that attracts architecture buffs and history enthusiasts alike. Beyond the academic appeal, Aurora enhances its quaint village charm with the Aurora Arts and Design Center and the headquarters of MacKenzie-Childs, where visitors can explore unique, whimsical designs in ceramics and home furnishings. This blend of history, education, and art creates a rich tapestry that, despite its depth and variety, has not led to Aurora becoming overrun with visitors, preserving its peaceful ambiance.

The village offers a range of water-based activities, such as kayaking and fishing, which appeal to those looking for an active retreat in a serene setting. For those preferring a leisurely pace, a stroll along the lakefront at sunset offers unforgettable views. The Inns of Aurora provide a sumptuous stay, converting historic homes into a sophisticated lodging experience that complements the village's historic charm. With its small population and community-focused lifestyle, Aurora remains a tightly knit community where visitors can experience a slower pace of life and immerse themselves in the local culture and natural beauty without the crowds found in more commercial destinations.

Hammondsport

Hammondsport is located at the southern end of Keuka Lake. Despite its small size, the town is steeped in significant cultural and historical contributions, most notably as the home of aviation pioneer Glenn H. Curtiss. The Glenn H. Curtiss Museum, a sprawling facility dedicated to his legacy, showcases an impressive collection of early aircraft, motorcycles, and automobiles that trace the evolution of early 20th-century transportation. This museum not only offers a deep dive into the history of aviation but also hosts exciting events such as air shows and car shows, making it a dynamic hub for history buffs and enthusiasts. Additionally, Hammondsport's charming Pulteney Square, a historic district with a quaint village green, provides a picturesque setting for leisurely strolls and relaxation, further enhancing its appeal as a peaceful getaway destination.

Hammondsport is celebrated as New York’s unofficial "Wine Capital," thanks to its pioneering wine industry. The town's vinicultural significance was cemented by Dr. Konstantin Frank, who introduced vinifera vines to the Eastern United States. Visitors can explore the Dr. Konstantin Frank Winery, where they can enjoy tastings of exquisite wines like Pinot Noir while taking in breathtaking views of Keuka Lake. For those interested in the broader history of winemaking, the Greyton H. Taylor Wine Museum offers insights into the local wine production and even features an intriguing collection of Presidential wine glasses.

Trumansburg

Trumansburg, situated just over 11 miles northwest of Ithaca and slightly inland from the southwestern shore of Cayuga Lake, is part of the town of Ulysses and offers a peaceful, small-town atmosphere coupled with easy access to some of the area’s most notable attractions. The proximity to Taughannock Falls State Park, home to a spectacular 215-foot waterfall—the tallest single-drop waterfall east of the Rocky Mountains—is a major draw. The park's vast network of trails and the scenic beauty of the falls make it a favorite for hikers and nature lovers. Additionally, Trumansburg serves as a gateway to the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail, America's first wine trail, providing an excellent base for exploring the rich viticulture of the region. The village's location also allows for quick trips to Ithaca, offering a contrast with its youthful, vibrant energy, thus providing visitors with a blend of tranquil rural charm and lively urban experiences.

The downtown area showcases well-preserved 19th-century buildings that reflect the community's commitment to maintaining its historical identity. Key landmarks include the Trumansburg Conservatory of Fine Arts, housed in a striking Greek Revival building dating back to 1851, and the Ulysses Philomathic Library, which stands out with its elegant pillars. These buildings not only enrich the aesthetic appeal of the village but also serve as focal points for community and cultural activities. For those looking to experience local culture, the Finger Lakes GrassRoots Festival of Music and Dance offers a lively celebration with a diverse array of music genres.

Penn Yan

As the heart of the Finger Lakes wine country, Penn Yan offers an enchanting blend of historical sites and vibrant cultural experiences. The village is home to Birkett Mills, one of the oldest mills in the United States, established in 1797, and a prominent fixture in the local community. History enthusiasts will revel in the expansive Historic Downtown, listed on the National Register of Historic Places, which boasts 281 historic buildings. These structures span a variety of architectural styles, from the Italianate Oliver House Museum, an 18-room mansion built in 1852, to smaller buildings dating back to the 18th century. The combination of these well-preserved sites with the village’s lush surroundings and proximity to world-class wineries makes Penn Yan an understated destination that offers a deep dive into America's past while being encased in scenic beauty.

Moreover, Penn Yan's appeal extends beyond its historical significance to include a thriving arts scene and community events that enrich the visitor experience. The Arts Center of Yates County, for instance, is a focal point for local and visiting art lovers, offering free access to exhibitions that showcase the talent within and beyond the region. For those who appreciate the outdoors, the Y-shaped Keuka Lake provides a stunning backdrop for water activities and lakeside relaxation. The nearby vineyards, such as Fox Run Vineyards and Dr. Konstantin Frank Winery, offer tours and tastings that highlight the area's agricultural bounty. Seasonal festivals, like the Keuka Arts Festival and the annual Harvest Festival, bring the community and visitors together in celebration of local crafts, foods, and wines.

Watkins Glen

Known primarily for its breathtaking Watkins Glen State Park, which boasts a dramatic gorge and cascading waterfalls accessible by an extensive network of trails, the town also harbors a deep-rooted racing heritage as the home of American road racing. This unique blend of pristine natural environments and a storied racing history creates a diverse visitor experience. Beyond the natural allure, Watkins Glen’s historical architecture adds another layer of intrigue; landmarks like the 18-room Victorian mansion Idlewild Inn and Glen Manor, the estate of town founder Dr. Samuel Watkins, showcase exceptional craftsmanship and architectural beauty from the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The Freer Opera House and a historic downtown district that includes structures like the original Fire Station and Hotel Kendall further highlight the town’s rich past, making Watkins Glen an ideal destination for those seeking a mix of scenic and cultural exploration.

Aside from its scenic trails and historical buildings, Watkins Glen excels in providing a lively downtown experience filled with quaint boutiques, chic eateries, and cozy accommodations. Nickel's Pit BBQ on N Franklin Street, known for its "phenomenal pig wings," and Seneca Harbor Station, a beautifully repurposed 1876 train station turned waterfront eatery, offer delightful dining experiences that pair local flavors with picturesque views. For visitors looking to extend their stay, the Watkins Glen Harbor Hotel, named “Best Waterfront Hotel in the Nation” by USA Today, offers luxurious lodgings right by the water. Additionally, the town’s vibrant community life is showcased in events like the Finger Lakes Wine Festival and races at the Watkins Glen International racetrack, providing engaging activities for visitors throughout the year.

Geneva

As a town with deep agricultural roots, Geneva is home to a thriving food scene that leverages its rich local produce, including fresh dairy, fruits, and vegetables. This abundance fuels a diverse culinary landscape featuring farm-to-table restaurants, craft breweries, and wineries, with places like Beef and Brew serving up a mix of British, Irish, and American fare that draws both locals and visitors alike. The town's commitment to showcasing local flavors extends to its wine culture, epitomized by the historic Belhurst Castle and Winery. Here, guests can indulge in tastings of award-winning wines within the walls of a 19th-century castle, offering a unique combination of historical architecture and modern indulgence. Moreover, Geneva’s proximity to Seneca Lake State Park allows for an array of outdoor activities such as hiking, biking, and boating, enhancing its appeal as a destination that caters to both culinary enthusiasts and nature lovers.

Geneva's beauty mirrors its European namesake, making it a picturesque and culturally enriching stop on the Finger Lakes circuit. The crystal-clear waters of Seneca Lake, the largest of the glacial Finger Lakes, provide a stunning backdrop for leisure and recreation. The Geneva Row Houses along Pulteney Park and Main Street add an architectural elegance reminiscent of Boston or Georgetown, creating a charming urban tapestry that complements the natural beauty. Cultural attractions like the Smith Opera House, with over a century of history, and the beautifully preserved Rose Hill Mansion offer visitors a glimpse into the area's past, enriching their experience with historical narratives and architectural grandeur.

Discover the untamed allure of the Finger Lakes, where hidden gems like Naples, Aurora, and Hammondsport await to enchant you with their unique charms. In these off-the-beaten-path towns, the essence of New York state unfolds in vibrant cultural scenes, rich histories, and breathtaking natural beauty. From tasting grape pies in Naples to exploring the nautical heritage of Hammondsport, each town offers a unique slice of serenity. Embrace the slower pace of life and rich tapestry of experiences in these less traveled yet profoundly captivating destinations of the Finger Lakes.