8 Budget-Friendly Towns In Indiana For Retirees

Most of us want to retire on the cheap — but not be in the middle of nowhere. Aspects like access to a decent hospital, a meaningful retail scene, and safe and peaceful neighborhoods are often the bare minimums. A sparkling lake, a pine-speckled mountain, or even quiet forest trails are bonuses. Fortunately, some of Indiana's most budget-friendly towns boast access to many great outdoor venues. Starting with New Castle, discover below the eight budget-friendly towns in Indiana.

New Castle

New Castle is a cute little town with a population known to be passionate about basketball. It is also fairly tight-knit and boasts a fantastic arts community. In June 2024, the median listing home price in New Castle was $154,900, earning it a spot among the most budget-friendly towns in the state. An empty nester here will be at the doorstep of Henry Community Health, a 2024 recipient of the Outpatient Orthopedic Surgery Award. She can canoe the Big Blue River as frequently as she likes, immerse herself in the region’s basketball history at the Indiana Basketball Hall of Fame, or hit up the small but lovely trail at Osborne Park. New Castle residents have a median age of 41, with residents aged 60 and above comprising 24% of the population.

Connersville

Connersville offers retirees the chance to go rafting at the Whitewater River, enjoy daily walks at the John Conner Nature Preserve Trail Park — and occasionally sit down to a slow brunch at one of the best Mexican restaurants in Indiana: El Caballo Blanco Mexican. There is Roberts Park as well, a lovely space with lots of happy squirrels, plus a large grassy area for picnicking. In June 2024, Connersville's median listing home price was $184,500, a price point that comes with ready access to Fayette Regional Health System, a long-running establishment whose history goes back more than a century. Connersville residents have a median age of 40, indicating a melting pot of demographics, with those aged 60 and above comprising 27% of the population.

Richmond

In June 2024, the median listing home price in Richmond was $169,900, a price point that earns the town a spot among the most budget-friendly Indiana towns. Those who want to retire close to an excellent hospital should particularly pay attention to Richmond. This is because Reid Health, originally founded in 1905, is a 2024 recipient of America's 250 Best Hospitals Award. Then again, Richmond is home to Earlham College, a private liberal arts college that has been around since 1847. An empty nester here can enjoy floating at Middle Fork Reservoir, boating at the East Whitewater River, or biking at venues such as Glen Miller Park and the Cardinal Greenway. Brace yourself for Richmond’s historic charm, well-preserved historic buildings, including a slew of Victorian-era homes, and its endearing small-town feel. Although the Richmond residents have a median age of 38, those 65 years and above represent a decent 18% of the population.

Peru

Small but loveable, Peru has been known as the "Circus Capital of the World." It hosts one of the oldest and best amateur circus performances on the planet. On parade day, typically held on the third week of July, music and cheers drift down Main Street as the town stages its largest festival. In June 2024, the median listing home price in Peru was $174,500. If under the weather, Dukes Memorial Hospital, which boasts a 24-hour emergency department, is right in town. Wabash River flows through the town, presenting a delicious range of recreational activities. Other venues a retiree will want to pay attention to include the Peru Disc Golf Course, Peru Skatepark, and the Peru Golf Course, which was built in 1926. Peru residents have a median age of 41, with those aged 60 and above comprising 25% of the population.

Logansport

To many retirees, the prospect of owning property for less than $200,000 is bound to be mouthwatering, regardless of location. That is the reason Logansport, which boasts a median listing home price of $178,000, should be of significant interest. Logansport Memorial Hospital is right in town, just in case one is worried about healthcare access. Some of the best recreational venues in and around Logansport include the Wabash River, which runs through the town; Riverside Park — and its paved walking trails — and the aptly named River Bluff Trail, which provides gorgeous views of the Eel River. Logansport residents have a median age of 37. Still, those aged 60 and above comprise 22% of the population. Many residents rave about Logansport’s small-town charm and close-knit community.

Wabash

In June 2024, the median listing home price in Wabash was $175,000. This comes with doorstep access to Parkview Wabash Hospital, which 77% of patients readily recommend. As a retiree here, you will be looking forward to the annual Wabash Cannonball Chili for Charity Cookoff, billed as the largest chili cookoff east of the Mississippi River. Safe and friendly for the most part, Wabash boasts several venues where an empty nester will enjoy spending time. This includes the Wabash River, which meanders through the town, Wabash City Park, which is endearingly peaceful and soothing; and the Honeywell Golf Course, a lovely public course suitable for all levels of golfers. Worried about the chances of linking up with fellow empty nesters? Wabash residents aged 65 and above comprise 17% of the town’s population.

Huntington

Decently maintained parks, neighborly attitude (for the most part), and proximity to Fort Wayne, which is just 25 miles down the road — are some of Huntington’s most retirement-friendly features. The median listing home price in Huntington was $239,900 in June 2024, which is an excellent bargain, especially considering what Huntington offers. There is the Parkview Huntington Hospital, readily recommended by 72% of patients — and Lutheran Health Network Orthopedic Hospital in Fort Wayne, a recipient of America's 50 Best Outpatient Orthopedic Surgery Award. On the social landscape, Huntington residents aged 60 and above comprise 22% of the population, meaning one will easily find folks in the same age bracket. Huntington University is in town, adding a layer of academic aura and a dash of vibrancy (and diversity) to the town’s cultural scene. Wabash River, the small but beautiful Sunken Gardens, Little River, and Lake Clare, are excellent boating sites. They all curate an experience that can see an empty nester age like fine wine.

Lake Station

Rounding off the list of the most budget-friendly towns in Indiana is Lake Station, a charming Indiana community that sits next to the waters of Lake Michigan. No one will want to overlook Lake Station, particularly because of its closeness to Chicago, which is just 38 miles down the road. Lake Station, therefore, boasts mouthwatering access to big-city amenities. The median listing home price in Lake Station is just $174,900. St. Mary Medical Center, a heartbeat away in Hobart, is a recipient of the Outstanding Patient Experience Award. Top-notch outdoor venues in and around Lake Station include Deep River, which flows through the town, Lake Station Pool @ Riverview Park, loved for its huge pool — and Countryside Park, which has a disc golf course, a nice walking path, and a cute, little pond. On the social side, Lake Station residents aged 60 and above comprise 20% of the population, meaning 1 in 5 residents may turn out to be fellow empty nesters.

The Takeaway

The median listing home price in Indiana — as of July 2024 — stood at $309,400. This makes “The Hoosier State” one of America’s most budget-friendly states. But the pricing scene is anything but uniform. The median listing price in the Angola area, for example, almost grazes the $500,000 mark. If you want to save on cash and still enjoy access to numerous desirable amenities, pay attention to spots such as New Castle, Connersville, and Lake Station, a lovely Chicago suburb with many reasonably priced homes.