aerial shot of the Red River in North Dakota

What Happens If The Mississippi Jumps Into The Red River

The Mississippi River is not supposed to be where it is today. Left alone, it would most likely have changed course decades ago and followed the Red River down a much shorter channel to the Gulf of Mexico. Government engineers saw it coming in the 1950s.

The only thing holding it back is a set of concrete gates in a quiet corner of Louisiana. Those gates have held for more than 60 years. Once, they very nearly didn't.

If they ever give way, the Mississippi might never come back. A small Louisiana town would suddenly find the full river at its door, and New Orleans would be left beside a channel that was no longer really the Mississippi. It all starts with a simple difference in distance.

The Mississippi Would Follow the Red River's Shortcut to the Gulf

Elevation model of the land between the Mississippi River, Old River, and the Atchafalaya River in Louisiana.
A NASA elevation model of the land between the Mississippi River, the Atchafalaya River, and Old River in Louisiana. Image credit: NASA.

The gates sit at Old River, a short channel near Simmesport, Louisiana, that connects two very different routes to the sea. Water that turns west through it joins the Atchafalaya, which runs south through swampland and reaches the Gulf in 142 miles. Water that stays in the Mississippi travels 335 miles, looping past Baton Rouge and New Orleans first. Both routes start at the same river level and end at sea level, so the shorter one is steeper.

Geologists call a river's switch to a steeper route an avulsion, and the Mississippi has made that switch many times. Over roughly the past 7,000 years, it has built six major delta lobes along the Louisiana coast by changing course, with a major new episode of delta building about once every 1,000 to 2,000 years. The youngest of the six is forming now at the mouth of the Atchafalaya.

The Jump Would Finish a Shift That Began in 1831

The Atchafalaya River in southern Louisiana.
The Atchafalaya River in southern Louisiana. Image credit: Shutterstock.com.

Before 1831, the Red River emptied into a 20-mile loop of the Mississippi called Turnbull's Bend, and the Atchafalaya branched off that same bend as a high-water outlet. That year, Henry Miller Shreve, who oversaw federal river improvements in the West, dug a channel across the neck of the bend to spare steamboats the long way around. The cut shortened the Mississippi by more than 17 miles. The upper arm of the old loop silted in, and the lower arm became Old River, a direct link between the Mississippi and the Atchafalaya.

A massive logjam still blocked the Atchafalaya, and the state of Louisiana began clearing it in 1839. Once the jam was gone, the channel widened to carry the extra water, and the wider channel drew still more. Under 10% of the combined flow of the Mississippi and Red at that latitude went down the Atchafalaya in 1850. A century later the share had reached 30%, and the Army Corps of Engineers' warning that the trend would end in capture led to the structures that hold the river today.

The Old River Gates Would Have to Fail First

The Old River Control Structure at the juncture of the Mississippi River and the Atchafalaya River.
The Old River Control Structure at the juncture of the Mississippi River and the Atchafalaya River, Public Domain

Congress authorized the Old River Control Project in 1954 and directed the Corps to hold the split at its 1950 level, with 70% of the combined flow staying in the Mississippi and 30% going to the Atchafalaya. The main tool is the Low Sill Structure, finished in 1963, a gated dam across the Old River connection that regulates the river's normal flow. The Corps adjusts the complex every day, opening gates when the Atchafalaya is getting less than its share and closing them when it is getting more. Beside the Low Sill, the Overbank Structure comes into use only when the Mississippi rises over its banks, and the Auxiliary Structure, built after the 1973 flood and finished in 1986, gives the Corps a second set of gates.

A flood big enough to top those structures has its own outlet. The Morganza Spillway, farther down the Mississippi near the town of Morganza, was built in 1954 to keep high water from overtopping the Old River complex. Its gates can send up to 600,000 cubic feet per second of the Mississippi into the Atchafalaya Basin, most of the flow the Old River structures carried at the peak of the 2011 flood.

A Flood Like 1973's Would Be the Most Likely Trigger

Landsat satellite image of the Morganza Spillway area in Louisiana during the 1973 flood.
A Landsat 1 satellite image of the Morganza Spillway area in Louisiana on May 5, 1973. Image credit: Landsat 1 via Wikimedia Commons, Public domain.

The structures had been working for a decade when the spring flood of 1973 hit. Water pouring through the Low Sill Structure scoured a hole 55 feet deep under its south end, undermining the foundation, and a wing wall failed. Crews dumped 250,000 tons of rock to stabilize it. The Atchafalaya's share of the flow rose to 34.6% that year, and the Corps opened 42 of Morganza's 125 gates on April 17 for the first time to lower the river. Writing in Eos in 2020, Tulane geologist Nicole Gasparini and Water Institute scientist Brendan Yuill concluded that without the control project, most of the flow would likely have switched to the Atchafalaya in 1973.

The structures have since held through the two highest floods on record at Old River. At the May 2011 peak, the complex passed 706,000 cubic feet per second into the Atchafalaya, and the Corps opened Morganza for the second time, partly to ease the pressure on the Old River gates. In 2019, the river was forecast to climb high enough to overtop Morganza itself, and the Corps announced a third opening, which in the end was not needed.

The foundation that the 1973 flood undermined is still in service. A $34.2 million contract awarded in 2023 called for draining the water away from the Low Sill Structure in 2024, the first time since 1987, so engineers could inspect it and make repairs.

Morgan City Would Take the Full Force of the Mississippi

Bridges crossing the Atchafalaya River at Morgan City, Louisiana.
Bridges across the Atchafalaya River in Morgan City, Louisiana. Image credit: Shutterstock.com.

If the Low Sill gave way during a flood, the water it was holding back would head south through the Atchafalaya Basin, which the U.S. Geological Survey calls the largest contiguous river swamp in the United States. The basin's floodway runs from Simmesport to the Gulf below Morgan City. Krotz Springs and Melville, two towns on the upper Atchafalaya, sit inside ring levees, and when Morganza opened in 2011, parts of Melville outside its levee were ordered to evacuate. Farther south, Interstate 10 crosses the swamp on an 18.2-mile bridge. Meteorologist Jeff Masters, who has written in detail about a failure at Old River, expects a new main channel to destroy pipelines, bridges, roads, and rail lines in its path.

Morgan City, a port town of 11,472 people at the 2020 Census, sits at the bottom of the basin behind a floodwall. The 1973 flood crested there at 10.5 feet, 2.5 feet below the top of the wall at the time, and industries on the river side took heavy losses. During the 2011 flood, the city closed 22 of its 27 floodgates. Asked by the Associated Press in 2018 what a capture would mean, Robert Twilley of Louisiana Sea Grant said, "Basically that whole region becomes inundated. Morgan City is gone, pretty much."

New Orleans Would Lose Its Drinking Water to the Gulf

The Mississippi River at New Orleans, Louisiana.
The Mississippi River at New Orleans, Louisiana. Image credit: Shutterstock.com.

On the old channel, the threat would come up from the Gulf. From just south of Natchez, Mississippi, about 348 miles above the mouth, the bed of the Mississippi lies below sea level, so dense salt water can creep upstream along the bottom whenever the current weakens. During the 2023 drought, a wedge of salt water moved into Plaquemines Parish, which lines the river's last 70 miles. The parish kept a drinking water advisory in place from June until October 18, and three of its five water treatment plants were compromised. The Corps built an underwater sill to slow the wedge and barged in fresh water, and Tulane University's Stephen Murphy estimated that close to 1 million people in greater New Orleans could be affected if the salt reached their intakes.

A captured river would make that drought condition permanent. With most of the Mississippi's water going west, Masters writes, the final 200-plus miles of the old channel would become a salt-water estuary of the Gulf, and salt might eventually push 230 miles upriver to Baton Rouge. Industries that draw fresh water from the lower river would be stranded beside a tidal channel. Nearly 1.5 million people in New Orleans, Metairie, Kenner, and the Houma and Thibodaux areas would lose their main source of drinking water.

Nearly Half of America's Grain Exports Would Be Cut Off From the Sea

A towboat pushing barges on the Mississippi River near Baton Rouge, Louisiana.
A towboat pushing barges on the Mississippi River near downtown Baton Rouge, Louisiana. Image credit: Shutterstock.com.

Most of the grain the Midwest sells overseas comes down the Mississippi by barge and is loaded onto oceangoing ships at elevators between Baton Rouge and the Gulf. Those Mississippi Gulf ports handled 48% of all U.S. grain inspected for export in 2024. A 1980 study titled "If the Old River Control Structure Fails?" listed the end of shipping to the Gulf on the old channel among the consequences of a capture. That would leave the grain elevators, and the more than 200 petrochemical plants and refineries along the same stretch of river, cut off from the shipping lane they were built around. Masters estimated in 2019 that closing the Mississippi to shipping would cost the economy $295 million a day.

The Mississippi Would Build a New Delta and Abandon the Old One

Satellite view of Atchafalaya Bay at the mouth of the Atchafalaya River in Louisiana.
The Atchafalaya River entering the Gulf at Atchafalaya Bay, Louisiana. Image credit: NASA Earth Observatory.

The Wax Lake Delta shows what the full river would build. An outlet dug in the early 1940s to lower floodwaters at Morgan City carries Atchafalaya water into the Gulf there, and new land at the river's mouth first rose above the water after the 1973 flood. NASA measured the Wax Lake and Atchafalaya deltas together growing by about a square mile a year. With the whole Mississippi behind them, they would receive the sediment that now travels down the old channel.

The Bird's Foot Delta at the tip of Plaquemines Parish, the outer tip of the Mississippi River Delta, would lose that supply. It receives less than 10% of the river's sediment for most of the year even now, and the USGS counts 2,006 square miles of Louisiana land lost between 1932 and 2016. Without the river's flow, the delta below New Orleans would have little left to rebuild it.

The force that would carry the Mississippi into the Red River's channel is the same one that dug a 55-foot hole under the Low Sill Structure in 1973. Fast water pouring toward the Atchafalaya scours the channel it runs through, and a deeper, wider channel then draws a larger share of the river, which scours it further. That cycle took the Atchafalaya from under 10% of the flow to 30% in a century, and it is the reason the Corps has held the split at the 1950 level for more than six decades. A failure at Old River would restart the cycle with nothing to slow it. Each flood would send more of the Mississippi west, until Morgan City sat on the river's main channel about 15 miles above its new mouth at Atchafalaya Bay, and the docks and water intakes between Baton Rouge and the Gulf faced a channel slowly filling with salt water.

Share

More in Bodies of Water